
by Tony d’Ambra
“Kathy, I’m lost,” I said, though I knew she was sleeping
I’m empty and aching and I don’t know why
Counting the cars on the New Jersey Turnpike
They’ve all gone to look for America
I was among the capacity crowd of over 20,000 for Simon & Garfunkel’s third and final Sydney concert Tuesday night. The duo started with Old Friends and finished with three encores. They performed all their big numbers, and were best when the musical backing was subdued. The are both hitting 70, but they never flagged over 2 hours with no intermission. Simon looks his age, while Garfunkel belies his years. Paradoxically, Simon’s voice still has a youthful clarity and range, while Garfunkel’s voice is straining but he gets there. Simon’s acoustic guitar accompaniment was languid and elegant. The highlight for me was the Gracelands set with Simon on his own at the microphone with additional backing from two musicians from the original Gracelands album and tour.
Tonight I’ll sing my songs again
I’ll play the game and pretend
But all my words come back to me
In shades of mediocrity
Like emptiness in harmony
I need someone to comfort me
I entered the arena with a sense of unease. Forty years since it all ended and now we were all of us visibly old and greying. There were some young people in the crowd, but we were most of us baby-boomers, clinging to a past gone forever, yet remaining important in our lives. We still wear blue jeans and think we’re cool, but the reality is confronting. You can fool yourself, but faced with thousands of others of your generation going to seed, the illusion collapses, and hard. My dear late mother in her twilight years used to say that she didn’t want to be with old people. I understand her now.
And a rock feels no pain;
And an island never cries.
Once I was seated though and I took in the empty stage lit in a calming blue light, the anticipation turned to excitement and awe. Finally, I would hear those songs of youthful melancholy sung for real for the first and probably the last time. The excitement was at fever pitch and when Simon & Garfunkel walked out to the front of the stage, the years fell away, and we yelled and whistled like teenagers.
But old father time had not finished with us yet. I was close to the stage but up high, and those guys on the stage could still have been 20 for all I could see. So I had to rely on the giant screen for the close-ups. The screen flickered into a montage with shots of the painfully young duo when they started their partnership morphing into the year leading up to their first break-up in 1969. Then they flashed for real onto the screen – looking as old and tired as the rest of us. They embraced that stark reality and quietly sang Old Friends from the Bookends album with only Paul Simon’s guitar as backing:
Old friends, old friends sat on their parkbench like bookends
A newspaper blowin’ through the grass
Falls on the round toes of the high shoes of the old friends
Old friends, winter companions, the old men
Lost in their overcoats, waiting for the sun
The sounds of the city sifting through trees
Settles like dust on the shoulders of the old friends
Can you imagine us years from today, sharing a parkbench quietly
How terribly strange to be seventy
Old friends, memory brushes the same years, silently sharing the same fears
So it was up-front and in the open now, they and we the audience were celebrating the past and myriad paths that had lead each of us to be here tonight together. This was not nostalgia or regret for the passing of the years, but a joyous reliving of our youth, our ravaged ideals, our lost innocence, our pain, the tragedies, and the fun.
In restless dreams I walked alone
Narrow streets of cobblestone
Beneath the halo of a street lamp
I turned my collar to the cold and damp
When my eyes were stabbed
By the flash of a neon light
That split the night
And touched the sound of silence
From this point for a too brief two hours we all became young again and shared songs of simple elegance shaped by poetic lyrics and haunting melody sung in graceful harmony.
In the clearing stands a boxer,
And a fighter by his trade
And he carries the reminders
Of ev’ry glove that laid him down
Or cut him till he cried out
In his anger and his shame,
“I am leaving, I am leaving.”
But the fighter still remains

Supporting line-up:
Warren Bernhardt – Piano
Charley Drayton – Drums
Jamey Haddad – Percusson
Bakithi Kumalo - Bass
Larry Saltzman – Guitar
Rob Schwimmer – Keyboards
Mark Stewart – Guitar
With Paul Simon:
Tony Cedras - Accordian & Keyboards
Vincent Nguini – Guitar
Andy Snitzer - Saxophone







This is a beautiful essay. Thank you so very much, Tony, for sharing this with us. The piece brought back nostalgic memories of the first time I had heard the music of Simon and Garfunkle. Like so many teenagers of the time and shortly thereafter, I was entranced by their songs of longing and sadness. They represented, for myself and an entire generation (along with the FAB FOUR) singular song-writers that spoke of what was inside us all. I first heard the duo, at least heard them to understand their meaning) when I was 14 years old. I was beginning my personal study of classic film and one of the cassettes I rented was Mike Nichol’s THE GRADUATE. The opening chords of SOUNDS OF SILENCE caught me off guard and it was a love affair with the duo and the film that has never diminished. Thanx again for this memorable essay. Dennis
Yes, Dennis, this is quite a beautiful, authoritative and reflective piece that Tony informs with a an exceeding sense of appreciation and intimacy.
When he told me about the concert a few days ago I was genuinely thrilled, as I have adored this duo since my childhood, and remember with fondness as a child rocking to the beat of THE SOUNDS OF SILENCE. Like Tony, I saw them in concert (actually not both but Paul Simon during his Graceland tour at Radio City Music Hall many years back). Paul Simon challenges Bob Dylan as the greatest American songwriter of all-time during the rock era, and only John Lennon edges ahead overall.
My favorite S & G album is BRIDGE OVER TROUBLED WATER, with BOOKENDS a close second.
My favorite S & G songs are:
The Boxer
Bridge Over Troubled Water
Old Friends
America
Scarborough Fair
Their harmonic felicity and profound lyrics remain at the center of American culture, informing an entire generation. Simon’s songwriting and musical stewardship was matched by Gurfunkle’s incomparable voice.
Tony magnificently captures the intimacy of his enviable experience and the awe-inspiring coda of witnessing this event in Sydney, and ‘becoming young again.’ Ah Tony, those were the days, and one can rightfully shed a few when recollecting. Rock music is more a specialty with you than even film noir. I’ve noticed that since we met.
That last picture reminds us that time is undaunted.
Thank you Dennis and Sam.
I nearly didn’t write the post, as I felt daunted and still do, by the power of the lyrics. While we must acknowledge Paul Simon’s creative genius as the songwriter, I feel there was a symbiosis during those iconic years in the 60s where Art Garfunkel must have inspired Simon, so their achievement should be justly shared.
The lyrics of those great songs stand as poetry of the highest order and speak universally, and this is why I chose to showcase those magic words and at least try to join them thematically with my very pedestrian prose.
Tony, A wonderful essay and look back at two great and influential artists. Like Dylan and Lennon, Paul Simon’s lyrics raised the bar to the highest artistic level. I was fortunate enough to see Paul Simon twice, first at the time of his “Still Crazy After All These Years” album at Lincoln Center and in Central Park during “The War is Over”(along with Pete Seeger, Joan Baez and others) rally.
What a captivating account of this singular event. I always think of them as having a huge influence on the cultural scene during the late 60′s, and one can never forget their score for “The Graduate” and of their most famous song, “Mrs. Robinson”.
–I entered the arena with a sense of unease. Forty years since it all ended and now we were all of us visibly old and greying. There were some young people in the crowd, but we were most of us baby-boomers, clinging to a past gone forever, yet remaining important in our lives.–
Very depressing.
With Michael Jackson’s untimely passing, it is kind of strange to be reading about Simon & Garfunkle, but the author here has no control over fate. Jackson himself thought highly of this duo, and of course Simon in particular. The use of the song lyrics throughout this piece transports to reader to Sydney, where this concert took place. My favorite album by this legendary duo is ‘Bookends’
Nostalgia runs through the entire review, but as so many of the older giants reach their twilights this is what is dominant. I had heard that Garfunkle’s voice was wavering, but your statement is good news.
What a trip down Memory Lane; wonderful review. I remember wearing out my vinyl copy of Graceland. I loved the song America most.
I wonder if this is a worldwide tour? I’d love to be able to get the chance to see these guys! I’m too young to say I appreciate them as much as Tony and others but I do love many of their songs.
“till he cried out
In his anger and his shame,
“I am leaving, I am leaving.”
But the fighter still remains”
This is one of the greatest songs ever written. it’s about the frustration, the hardship, and the struggles in this life, but it’s also about perseverence. I think I read that it was Garfunkle’s idea to have that sudden musical silence.
Such fantastic comments! I’m sure Tony will address them, but John I envy you for seeing them twice, and Mike I can’t agree with you more on those lyrics for THE BOXER!
They are among my favorite groups of all-time. I would assume this will probably be their last tour together. It’s something never to be forgotten, and I commend you Sir on a terrific recap.
An impeccably detailed account, Tony. Thank you so much for sharing this with all of us. And I must say your writing is far from pedestrian–you transported us to the event in a way that is effulgent yet tender. I never have seen Simon & Garfunkel live, but thanks to you I can now imagine it, in any event. Take care.
Thank you all for your responses and sharing your own feelings and experiences.
The timing of the piece was sadly ironic, but the Grim Reaper keeps to his own schedule.
This is their first tour together in 5 years, and takes in Australia, New Zealand, and Japan. No other tours are planned at present.
Of the three ‘encores’ on Tuesday night, the first two were clearly ‘organised’ as the songs were The Sound of Silence and The Boxer, but the third was I think spontaneous. From their faces S&G were clearly thrilled with the audience, and Paul Simon asked the band if it was ok to go for a third, and after Simon said “and I HATE this song”, they sang Feelin’ Groovy…
I know it is rather strange talking about S & G at the time of Michael Jackson’s untimely passing, but Mr. d’Ambra admits the Grim Reaper has no schedule. But perhaps we can say up front that both Jackson and this pair are among the greatest in the history of popular music. True, Jackson is larger than life and is an icon in the most assertive expression of that word. Still S & G represented the most profound expression of the term “popular music”. I know Paul made his rounds as a solo artist, but it’s great to see these two have reconciled, even though this tour won’t be coming in this direction. The entire S & G experience is lovingly conveyed in this review.
I’ve heard about this tour, and am happy to see someone attended and reviewed it online. It’s a very fine recap. I think Simon’s solo carrer at least came close to eclipsing his creativity with Art. The songs mentioned here by their lyrics are justly famous. I guess nobody knows that Jacques Brel’s ‘Old Folks’ influenced ‘Old Friends’
I wish I could have attended this. But I couldn’t afford the plane fare. With all this talk about Michael Jackson and his music, this duo imprssed me as much as anyone else did while growing up. You rekindled the old flame.
nice hearing from you Conrad! Thanks Peter and Robert. Yes, the timing with Michael Jackson’s death was at Tony notes “most ironic.”
thanks for lovely piece-i saw them last night in perth and felt similar emotions!
i didn’t buy a program as forgot to bring cash and am wondering if you have a list of the names of the musicians??
they were brilliant and i didn’t catch many of their names when simon and garfunkel were thanking them at the end.
hope you can help!
thankyou,
ellie
Thanks ellie. Sorry I didn’t get a program, and I can’t recall the names of the other band members, which is a shame as they were brilliant. I have tried Googling for the info, but have not been successful.
Just seen thos article and dont know if you received a reply but the musicians were
Warren Bernhardt piano
Charley Drayton Drums
Jamey Haddad Percusson
Bakithi Kumalo Bass
Larry Saltzman Guitar
Rob Schwimmer Keyboards
Mark Stewart Guitar
additional with Paul
Tony Cedras Accordian Keyboards
Vincent Nguini Guitar
Andy Snitzer Saxophone
i agree brilliant musicians they have performed with Paul for many years.
Great Brenda – thank you so much! I have added the line-up to the original post.