by Allan Fish
(Germany 1926 116m) DVD2 (DVD1 export version only)
Aka. Faust: Eine Deutsche Volkssage
Go to a cross road and call upon him three times
p Erich Pommer d Friedrich W.Murnau w Hans Kyser books Johann Wolfgang Von Goethe ph Carl Hoffman ed Friedrich W.Murnau m Werner R.Heymann, Erno Rapee (Timothy Brock 1997/2006 restoration) art Robert Herith, Walter Röhrig cos Georges Annekov
Gösta Ekman (Faust), Emil Jannings (Mephistopheles), Camilla Horn (Gretchen), Yvette Guilbert (Marthe Schwertdlein), William Dieterle (Valentin, Gretchen’s brother), Frida Richard (Gretchen’s mother), Eric Barclay (Duke of Parma), Hanna Ralph (Duchess of Parma), Werner Fuetterer (Archangel),
At the time I write in 2006, we have become accustomed to, and somewhat take for granted, the sterling efforts of film restorers to bring the masterpieces of yore back to gleaming cinematic life, making them look arguably better than they did even on release. In 2006, however, a further step was taken that is unlikely to be repeated; up until that time the only version of Murnau’s silent masterpiece seen was commonly referred to as the ‘export version’, which was made up of takes which Murnau discarded from his perfectionist German print. Even in that almost second-hand form it was a near masterpiece, but the release in 2006 of that original, long thought lost German version, was more than a subject for rejoicing, it was almost a cinematic epiphany.
Murnau’s vision borrows heavily from various previous interpretations by Goethe, Marlowe and Gounod, and shows the fight between the forces of darkness, and those of light personified by an unnamed archangel. The Devil, Mephistopheles, wagers the archangel that, if he can turn the almost saintly old professor and theologian Faust to the dark side, as it were, the forces of light must surrender the Earth to the forces of darkness. Mephisto spreads a pestilent plague on Faust’s home town from which few are spared and, in his desperation to save his townsfolk, Faust makes a fateful decision.
Even now the film resonates with influential power. There has probably never been a film so influential to Walt Disney than this. The magnificently apocryphal opening sequence, ending with Mephisto casting his shadowy cape over the town, was mixed with sequences in Christensen’s Häxan to become the ‘Night on Bald Mountain’ sequence in Fantasia, while decades later, the sequence of Mephisto turning Faust into a royal emissary with elephants was directly copied in Aladdin. He also drew heavily on what can only be described as the perfect mixture of Gothic and expressionistic art in some truly stunning sets designed by those masters Röhrig and Herlth, whose best work this may well be. Even the model and trick work is stunning for its day and holds up remarkably well eighty years on. Murnau also shows his mastery of narrative strength, pulling you in from the very opening caption – “Behold, the portals of darkness are open, and the shadows of the dead hunt over the earth” – to the truly heartrending finale as hero and heroine are consumed by flames, and the original tale of faith and redemption becomes a critique of man’s inhumanity to man. Praise, too, for the cast; Ekman is touching as the tragic Faust, and Horn is quite indescribably lovely as the truly tragic Gretchen (and according to Brownlow’s Cinema Europe, she really suffered in her own equivalent of the Via Dolorosa sequence), whose ethereal beauty obviously influenced Murnau’s depiction of Janet Gaynor in the later Sunrise. Dominating all, though, is Jannings, in one of his truly most memorably insidious performances, as devilish a Satan as we have ever seen, almost praising himself when he cries out “no man can resist evil”, acting as censor to Faust’s lovemaking by bringing his colossal cape down over the bed, or simply plotting against any shred of true love. Note also the presence in the cast of a young William Dieterle, who would pay the ultimate complement by making his own masterful take on Faust fifteen years later (All That Money Can Buy), and they make so devilishly intoxicating a double bill as to make most directors sell their soul to make a film as good as either.








If you put a gun to my head and told me, without hesitating, to name the twenty greatest directors in film, most assuredly F. W. Murnau would make the top ten with the likes of Bergman, Eisenstein, Kubrick, Chaplin, Renoir and Welles. His contribution to cinema cannot be completely calculated as it is so vast. His experimentation, perfectionism and guts are all legendary. This director, I have a feeling, is going to be represented in this count a few more times and, I’ll lay big money, guite highly. We have yet to see SUNRISE or his amazing NOSFERATU surface. A canon of films that is like no other, Murnau was a gift to the art of film. His movies entrance new audiences even after 80 years. He is often called a legend, and I would never go against that praise. This is just one of many masterworks coming out of one of the greatest directors there ever was… He was, simply, a genius.
Faust (the export version, at least) has several spectacular set pieces and probably the best Jannings performance that I’ve seen. He’s better here, I think, than in The Last Laugh, though that’s a better Murnau movie.
Samuel, I consider his performance in THE LAST LAUGH as his greatest, thout this one is also superlative. And yes, THE LAST LAUGH is the greater film, and deserves a very high placement on this countdown, which I believe it will get from Allan.
Sam, Jannings is obviously great in Last Laugh also, but the part requires him to lay the pathos on just a little too thick for my taste, compared to his more amusing antics in Faust.
This is my favorite Murnau.
1. Sunrise
2. The Last Laugh
3. Nosferatu
4. Faust
5. City Girl
6. The Burning Soil
7. Tabu
8. Phantom
9. The Grand Duke’s Finances
10. Tartuffe
Well, Joel there’s my own top ten numerically.
1. SUNRISE 2. Nosferatu 3. TARTUFFE 4. The Last Laugh 5. FAUST-I have yet to see CITY GIRL. D films listed for me will have to suffice. Also, I will add that although I feel SUNRISE is Murnau’s greatest film, his NOSFERATU goes down in my book as the CREEPIEST movie EVER made. Still gives me the willy’s after seeing it again and again over 25 years since I saw it the first time. Nice write up, Alllan! Ciao! Dennis
F. W. Murnau
Alfred Hitchcock
Carl Theodor Dreyer
Ingmar Bergman
Yasujiro Ozu
Chales Chaplin
Max Ophuls
Buster Keaton
Orson Welles
Preston Sturges
Kenji Mizoguchi
Robert Bresson
Marcel Carne
Jean Cocteau
Jacques Rivette
Michaelangelo Antonioni
Pier Paulo Pasolini
Nicholas Ray
Douglas Sirk
Terrence Davies
Stanley Kubrick
Bernardo Bertolucci
Terrence Malick
Dzeiga Vertov
Julian Duvuvier
Louis Malle
Anthony Mann
Lars Von Trier
Budd Boeticher
Woody Allen
Hans-Jurgen Syberberg
Henri-Georges Clouzot
James Whale
Jacques Tourneur
Keisuke Kinoshita
George Cukor
Akira Kurosawa
Erich Von Stroheim
Jean Renoir
Vsevolod Pudovkin
Sidney Lumet
Victor Sjostrom
Michael Powell/Emeric Pressburger
Sir Carol Reed
Luis Bunuel
Orson Welles
John Ford
Frank Capra
Ernst Lubitsch
Joseph Von Sternberg
Rene Clair
Maya Deren
Humphrey Jennings
Franticek Vlacil
Mikio Naruse
Billy Wilder
Satijit Ray
Cecil B. DeMille
Ouseme Sembene
Abbas Kiarostami
Krzysztof Kieslowski
Sergio Leone
Miklos Jansco
William Dieterle
Werner Herzog
Abel Gance
Apichatpong Weerasetnakul
Rainer Warner Fassbinder
D. W. Griffith
Martin Scorsese
David Lynch
Francis Ford Coppola
Ken Loach
Steven Spielberg
Fritz Lang
G.W. Pabst
Jane Campion
Andrei Tarkovsky
Sergei Eisenstein
Alexander Dovshenko
Otto Preminger
King Vidor
Michael Curtiz
Elia Kazan
Jacques Feyder
Francois Truffaut
Jean-Luc Godard
Jean-Pierre Melville
Eric Rohmer
Vittoris De Sica
Federico Fellini
Howard Hawks
Luchino Visconti
Kon Ichikawa
Nagisa Oshima
Yusuzo Masumura
Andrei Tarkovsky
Jacques Tati
Alain Resnais
Fred Zinnemann
William Wyler
Maurice Pialat
Vincente Minelli
William Wellman
Frank Borzage
Claude Chabrol
Milos Foreman
Andrezej Wajda
Irissa Oudreago
Harold Lloyd
Jean Vigo
Todd Haynes
Mike Leigh
Dardenne brothers
Jires Menzel
Well, there’s well over 100, and doesn’t even include Victor Fleming, who is 1939 directed two of the greatest and most beloved films in history.
And the contemporary avante garde people too.
And then there are the co-directors of SINGIN IN THE RAIN as well. How do you choose 20 of these?
Note: The above list is presented in NO particular order whatsoever.
Call the Doctor, Sam’s Listitis has struck again, chronic bout…out of nowhere, an unprovoked listing…LOL
BTW – Is Jires Menzel the hybrid black sheep marriage between Jiri Menzel and Jaromil Jires?
Harold Lloyd didn’t direct his films, Sam Taylor and Fred Newmeyer did a few of them.
And much as I love Abel Gance, you can’t count him twice.
And no Rivette, Huston, Antonioni, Whale, McCarey, Altman, Bertolucci, Coens, Duvivier, Walsh, Malick, Kobayashi, Malle, Allen, Davies, Leone, Mamoulian, Jancso, Leisen, Lumet, Milestone, Reitz, Yimou, Tourneur, Herzog, Polanski, Mann, Mackendrick, Von Trier, Kinoshita, Riefenstahl, Shimizu, Syberberg, Yoshida, Rohmer, Fassbinder, Pasolini, Pudovkin, Anderson, Vertov, Feuillade, Yang, l’Herbier, Bernard, Rossellini, Yamanaka, N Ray or your beloved Sirk, but room for Campion and Haynes due to your love for one film apiece? Tish and Pish!
Allan, the list was grossly incomplete, but i was unable to get to a PC at school. I even forgot Kubrick, Pasolini, Boeticher and a few others, which you didn’t pick up. I balk at including Shimizu, Mackendrick, Anderson, Feuillade, Yang, L’Herbier, Yoshida, Reifenstahl, and Yamanaka, but they do push close. I already had Rohmer, Pudovkin and Vertov on the list. Sirk was one of the first ones I wrote on a preliminary list, but didn’t transfer it. And I like Haynes for 3 films, not one (FAR FROM HEAVEN, I’M NOT THERE, SAFE) Similarly, with BRIGHT STAR, THE PIANO and AN ANGEL AT MY TABLE I like Ms. Campion for 3 as well.
You balk at l’Herbier as you have only watched one of his films and refuse to watch any more. But anyone including Haynes above Anderson is, quite frankly, a lunatic, when THERE WILL BE BLOOD and MAGNOLIA are both better than anything Haynes has produced.
And Ouedraogo for TILAI (you haven’t seen YAABA) but balk at Shimizu or Yoshida? Let’s not go there.
Having seen Nosferatu years ago, and enjoying the set especially, we managed to see The Last Laugh and did not realize at the time it was directed by the same person. It has become a favorite that we will watch again.
Will have to see a few more after reading what ya’ll have written.
Cheers!
Since we’re listmongering here, let me say that FOUR DEVILS is the lost film from silent days that I’d most like to see. That’s how much I like Murnau.
Second only to Von Stroheim’s The Honeymoon, Samuel.
If we’re going to choose Directors who have more than one excellent work it’d have to be these nine:
Jean-Luc Godard
Andrei Tarkovsky
Satyajit Ray
Hayao Miyazaki
Kieslowski
Kenji Mizoguchi
FW Murnau
Hou Hsiao Hsien
David Lynch
You chose Welles and Tarkovsky twice too, Sam.
I’d pick Tarkovsky three times and Welles….well, you know.
Btw Sam, what’s your take on Bela Tarr (he’s not on your list)?