by Allan Fish
(USA 1928 75m) not on DVD
The dreaded Norther
p Lillian Gish, Victor Sjöstrom d Victor Sjöstrom w Frances Marion, John Colton novel Dorothy Scarborough ph John Arnold ed Conrad A.Nervig m Carl Davis art Cedric Gibbons, Edward Withers cos André-Ani
Lillian Gish (Letty Mason), Lars Hanson (Lige Hightower), Montagu Love (Wirt Roddy), Dorothy Cummings (Cora), Edward Earle (Beverly), William Orlamond (Sourdough),
“This is the story of a woman who came into the domain of the winds” the opening captions read and, if ever a film could be described as tempestuous, it’s this one. One of the last great silents of the American screen, along with The Wedding March, The Crowd and Docks of New York it represented the final zenith of that soon to be outmoded art form. The coming of talkies seemed predestined to arrive in time for the post 1929 depression, and the cinema would once more push art aside in favour of entertainment.
Letty Mason is travelling from her Virginia home to her cousin’s small ranch at the desert post of Sweet Water (did this influence Leone’s like-named ranch in Once Upon a Time in the West, where Claudia Cardinale is travelling by train in the opening sequence?). Arriving, she immediately causes her cousin’s stern wife to grow jealous, the latter accusing her of trying to lure her cousin from his wife. Letty is proposed to by two local hicks, Lige and Sourdough, though she rather prefers the attentions of scoundrel Wirt Roddy (anagram of ‘dirty word’). But when she shows up to marry him, he tells her of his previous marriage and she is forced to marry Lige. However, in refusing to allow him to consummate their marriage, Lige is driven to desperate measures to raise money to send her off back where she came from. Roddy, meanwhile, has designs of his own.
With the possible exception of the finale of Greed, no other silent film was shot in such harsh surroundings. Shot on location in the Mojave Desert, the shooting took its toll on both the cast and crew. Sjöstrom, Gish, Hanson and Marion had previously collaborated on The Scarlet Letter in 1926, but The Wind is in every way a superior film. No other film has so depicted the violence of the eponymous weather out in the desert, the loneliness, the unbearable noise that the wind creates (remarkable, considering it’s a silent). Indeed John Arnold’s photography is quite amazing, considering the difficulties that the shoot would create. There’s a true sense of the dusty, windswept barrenness of the desert that cannot be described, only seen. Yet this visual atmosphere is only the flake on the 99, the real power coming in the emotional maelstrom that forms the centre. Gish may look the same frail girl of the Griffith films over a decade earlier, but there’s a sense of the frontier spirit to her Letty, the same resilience as would drive on her matriarchs in the likes of Duel in the Sun and The Unforgiven. Despite actually being 31 at the time of shooting, Gish is quite wonderful as young Letty. The numerous shots of her holding her arms up to her face, almost stretching the very fabric of her physiognomy to suggest real terror and frustration at her surroundings, is breathtaking. It’s her greatest performance, dominating the film from start to finish. Even so, it would be too easy to forget the contribution of Sjöstrom. It’s a crying shame that, if asked to name Sjöstrom’s greatest contribution to film, 90% of film buffs would wax lyrical about his monumental performance in Bergman’s Wild Strawberries. Too many forget he was one of the major directors of the old Swedish cinema and directed this true masterpiece of the late Hollywood era. There’s a sense of true majesty at the power of nature, unforgettably symbolically represented by Gish’s numerous visions of the Norther wind as a ghost horse that lived in the clouds (as dreamt by the native Americans) and depicted in an incredibly dramatic sandstorm in which Roddy returns to the lone Letty and tries to rape her (uncannily recalling the rape of Susan George in the later Straw Dogs). And though many might complain at the weakness of the tacked on happy ending, in the end one is too awestruck to really mind. One should petition Ted Turner immediately to get his studio bosses off their derrières and restore this on DVD to a grateful world.








Wow.
This sounds fantastic, you’ve sent me scurrying to procure a copy. This screen cap looks to be pretty decent quality, care to point me in the direction of where you found yours?
Oh, and this goes without saying almost, fantastic review. Impassioned, and extremely knowledgeable (as I’ve pointed out before I adore how you effortlessly mix films sometimes 50 years and languages apart). At some point you need to post some piss poor reviews to remind us how good this writing is.
A demur woman holding a gun. Is there a more cinema image (the twist is how unsure it looks)?
I wish my print was this good, Jamie, but it isn’t. This pic is from the net.
Oh, and I think I have posted some piss poor reviews in my time, thankfully people have been diplomatic enough not to point it out.
I have a copy floating around here somewhere is this mess, but it was created from the laserdisc. When I find it, I’ll notify you Jamie! This is Top 10 material for me, one of the greatest silent films ever made—one of the greatest films ever made period–Lillian Gish’s greatest performance ever–and the greatest use of weather in the history of the cinema (Kobayashi’s film is runner-up). You have reason to be excited Jamie!!!
The biggest injustice in the DVD market to this point is the inexplicable (and criminal) unavailability of THE WIND, THE CROWD, GREED and THE BIG PARADE on legitimate DVD.
I complain about this almost every time I speak with Allan on the phone.
PLEASE Warners, do something finally!!!!!!!!
YES, YES!!!! Couldn’t agree more. Schmulee showed this to me years on the very Laserdisc he’s speaking of above. This is a riveting, atmospheric and jaw-dropping film in every way, shape and form. I agree with Allan though. Its saf that Sjorstrom’s celebrity is usually confined to his tremendous WILD STRAWBERRIES performance and NOT for his work here and others of the early period of film. Gish? What can I say? This performance ranks as one of the 25 greatest in film history and, in the silent period, second only to Falconeddi’s immortal turn in Dreyer’s PASSION OF JOAN OF ARC. I agree, wholeheartedly with Allan and Sam her: THIS IS A MASTERPIECE (one of few). Great essay Allan, beautifully composed.
And yes, Schmulee DOES complain about this film not being released on DVD. Its a shame, really. By not giving this film the ayttention it deserves, guys like Turner are robbing the public of a one-of-a-kind experience. Personally, I feel that classic films, once entered into the National Film Registry, should be forever available for easy viewing by anyone interested. Like a library, these films should be made available on disc or streaming down-load on the internet. I shudder to think that kids like Sam’s might be deprived the pleasure and education of essential films like THE WIND. If our youths were exposed to stuff like this at an earlier age, rather than 99% of the crap they see fresh every week on TV, the world would be a better, nicer, smarter place.
And Gish, well, she was a trooper all her life. Never brought down by the talkies, she fought her way through harsh times and surfaced for many decades to stay visible. Here, she triumphs in one of the greatest of all performances. NIGHT OF THE HUNTER in the 50′s proved that she stll had the stuff, her performance is radiant. And, in the 80′s, in the throws of the oldest of old age, she bangs one out of the park in THE WHALES OF AUGUST. She was visibly talented from the start and aged like a fine wine. If there were a few that had the right to be labeled LEGEND, then she, absolutely, is one of them. A class act in every sense of the word and an inspiration for people like Meryl Streep, Helen Mirren, Susan Sarandon, Glenn Close etc.
Dennis said,
“Like a library, these films should be made available on disc or streaming down-load on the internet.”
Hi! Dennis,
In the meantime, You can watch the 1928 film The Wind over there on The Googler in its entirety!
Lillian Gish in the “Wind”…
DeeDee
That’s an interesting piece of information. Thank You So Much, DEE-DEE, you’re a real peach. Unfortunately, I don’t have a working PC (saving to by the BIG Apple Desk-Top. Was wondering, is this GOOGLER place on-line host to other films? Might be a good site to list on the side scroll for readers to click on if they cqannot find the films in traditional DVD format. Again, thanks. Dennis
Dennis, a man after my own heart! I am a long Mac user/devotee (I come from graphics background so I didn’t really have a choice at the beginning). If you every need any tips, links, or software type hints just let me know.
I honestly believe a power Mac is like a nice English car; you should get to zip around in one at least once in your life.
Allan said,”And though many might complain at the weakness of the tacked on happy ending, in the end one is too awestruck to really mind.”
@Allan…Once you listen to Miss Gish, you will find that she was in agreement with you, about the “tacked” on ending.
Allan said,”One should petition Ted Turner immediately to get his studio bosses off their derrières and restore this on DVD to a grateful world…”
Dennis said,”That’s an interesting piece of information. Thank You So Much, DEE-DEE…”
Dennis, Thanks and you’re very welcome…and Allan, I agree with you, but did you and (the readers, here at Wonders in the Dark) know that this film is available on VHS and was released by MGM/UA…Therefore, if you own a DVD/VHS combo (Unfortunately, I do own a DVD/VHS combo…) you will be able to view this films in your…lifetime. (Well, until it’s released in the DVD format.)
“The Wind” over there on Amazon.com
DeeDee
Yes, but we have DVDRs of the old VHS print, in my case taken from Channel 4 TV with the self-same Gish intro.
Hi! Allan,
Allan said,”Yes, but we have DVDRs of the old VHS print, in my case taken from Channel 4 TV with the self-same Gish intro.”
Oops! I wasn’t aware of that…as a matter of fact, I was introduced to this film earlier this year…Thanks, to my Thursday Theme group members.
Because the theme was…Wind and when I did a google search…lo and behold…this title appeared.
(Hence, my great interests in this Lillian Gish /Victor Sjöstrom(?!? I’am not familiar with him or his work on film…”yet” with yet being the “operative” word.)
vehicle…)
Thanks, for sharing!
DeeDee
Thanks DeeDee for the link(s), as I ‘wait’ for my copy–which looks to be a similar print to the one on google–I think I’ll just watch it there. Can’t wait.
Speaking of Lillian Gish, what are the opinions around here of ‘Duel in the Sun’? I think it’s really something everyone should see, a product of its time, and pretty out there. But a fun watch nonetheless.
Gish’s greatest performances Jamie, were in THE WIND and BROKEN BLOSSOMS (Griffith), but DUEL IN THE SUN does feature an unforgettable performance by her as well!!!!! Nice one!!!!
Once again, that extraordinary blogger and dearest of friends Dee Dee, has embellished this thread with incomparable additions, comments and that marvelous Lillian Gish interview to the VHS version of THE WIND. And Dennis Polifroni is also at the top of his game with tremendous comments and true passion!!! But few films on this marathon countdown deserve this kind of adoration, and I will search to find my copy. It’s here in this computer room, Dee Dee and Jamie!
To Dee Dee and Dennis: I salute you.
BTW Dee Dee, I am just now looking over the interview questions by e mail, and will move to answer these. I just got back from a DEVASTATINGLY brilliant French film called UN PROPHETE, and have the Asian film MOTHER lined up for tonight with Lucille and Bob in a raging NYC rainstorm!
Dennis said,”Was wondering, is this GOOGLER place on-line host to other films? Might be a good site to list on the side scroll for readers to click on if they cannot find the films in traditional DVD format…
Dennis, I’am quite sure that Google members,
post numerous hard to find films over there on Google…Because Tony, is constantly linking to Google videos when it comes to posting hard-to-find films (links)…back here on Wonders in the Dark.
DeeDee
Of course I do know what Allan’s #15 film is, and it will be unveiled tomorrow. It is also a staggering American silent masterpiece, and let’s just say it’s “connected” in a sense to THE WIND. I can’t give away any further clues or Allan will have my head. it’s less than 7 hours to post time! Ha!
But it’s simply one of the greatest of all films.
@Hi! Jamie,
You’re very welcome!
@Hi! Sam Juliano,
Take your time… when it comes to responding to those questions…
…believe me there is no deadline.
Take care!
DeeDee
A fine review, Allan. I have just one cavil, and that is that Wirt Roddy doesn’t “try” to rape Letty–he does so, when she’s fainted from terror. The reason I think this is important to clear up is that the most powerful, and yet subtle, acting of Gish’s career comes in the next scene. She’s just undergone what most at that time would have considered the worst possible disaster of a woman’s life. Earlier in the movie Letty has shown us so much of her fragility, and indeed hysteria. We would expect her to be a shattered wreck after the attack. But instead we see a different, strong, adult Letty. She’s sitting at the table–she’s put her hair back up, a small but poignant detail that signifies her self-control and self-respect. Her whole aspect is different. There are tragic lines in her face, and a weary knowledge, but she has moved past shock to a slowly growing determination and rage. When Roddy threatens her again and she shoots him down, we believe she could do it; but does anyone believe that the earlier Letty, a foolish girl, could even have held the heavy gun?
In this scene she shows us every thought of a character forced by brutal circumstances to evolve, in a few minutes, and with hardly a word of dialogue. Yes, she is remarkable. I absolutely agree that her performance is one of the very finest gems from the silents.
Typical Margaret here. Always a top-rank, acute observation, and I’m inclined to agree here. Fecund work here from first word to last. Thank you again.
Thanks for a awesome post and interesting comments. I found this post while looking for some music news updates. Thanks for sharing this article.
SAM is gonna look for a lost DVD in the COMPUTER ROOM!!!!! LOL!!!! You got a better chance of finding Kennedy’s assasin than you do that disc. Count his copy of THE WIND as GONE WITH THE WIND. I think I saw Gillian and Dan (Sam’s second daughter ans Sam’s little psycho) tossing it around in the back yard as a frisbee. Next week the kids are gonna use all of his Caldecott Award Books to build Joanie (Sam’s over-eating Labredor-Retriever) a new dog house. I caught one of the kids using his BLUE-RAY disc of WALL-E as a coaster during an illicit poker game. The winner gets Sam’s entire collection of FILM SCORE MONTHLY. Not surprisingly, nobody wanted play….
JAMIE-No question that Sam has CORRECTLY sited Gish’s best turns above. But, if you go deeper into the films he has mentioned and see each one, you’ll agree that it is, indeed, this film, THE WIND, that Allan has so brilliantly written about her biggest triumph. Her turn here is a text book example of the true art of silent screen acting. Personally, I think its the only FEMALE performance to give PASSION OF JOAN OF ARC’s Falconeddi a run for the money, and we know THAT performance is DEFINATELY in the TOP 10 of the best in all of FILM HISTORY. So, do the math. No, no. The other Gish performances are great, but THE WIND is her jaw-dropper. Gish and Sjorstrom were on the same creative eave-lengths and were like the two halves that make up one brain. Gish even helped produce THE WIND, she was that passionate over it. Well, the passion shows with one of the TITANIC screen performances of the 20th century. See it. Never forget it. Gish was a goddess of the form.
YES, YES, MARGARET!!!!! Good point!!!! Its those mature, determined details that send Gish’s performance into the stratosphere. JAMIE-this is EXACTLY a perfect example of the creativity and lived in brilliance that Lillian Gish brought to THE WIND and other performances in her canon. She NEVER makes a wrong turn. MARGARET is exactly right and deserves thanks for illustrating this (and a lot faster than I was to get to it). There are great actors and there are UNTOUCHABLE actors. Lillian Gish, along with Marlon Brando, Katharine Hepburn, Lionel Barrymore, Spencer Tracy, Anna Magnani, Max Von Sydow, Laurence Olivier, James Stewart, Marlene Dietrich, Liv Ullman (just to name a few) were, indeed, UNTOUCHABLE. We’ll never (well, maybe Meryl Streep, Jack Nicholson, Daniel Day-Lewis) see their likes again (oh, I forgot to mention Paul Newman and Sean Penn). Its guys and gals like that who have the mold broken… Gish was one of the standard-setters. They all, who come after her, learn from her. She sizzles!!!!!
Seriously why is this not on DVD? I remember studying this in film class and I always took for granted that I would easily be able to watch the whole thing when the time came…drats!
I absolutely love the screenshot! Gish’s body language, the way she is holding the gun…the unseen “Wind” having blown open the door revealing…an intruder?? Perfect pic!
David, it’s not being on DVD is criminal. There is no worst oversight in the entire breath of the DVD catalogue. Great comment David!
Oddly enough, I enjoyed Scarlet Letter more than this but I think that’s down to mostly extraneous factors – among other things, greater interest in the setting of SL and also the fact that SL was in much, much better condition than The Wind – screened on TCM while Wind was watched on the computer. I’ll definitely watch it again, probably in the next month or two. Still, I do think you underrate SL by not including it in the top 100; I asked you this before (and maybe you responded, sorry) but why so low?
Joel, of course you like THE SCARLET LETTER better!! You are from BAH-STON!!!! LOL!!!!!
Just kidding. Actually I’ve sparred with Allan on occasion about THE SCARLET LETTER. He likes it a lot, but doesn’t rate it here in this countdown, and thinks THE WIND is far better. I’ll say it’s extremely close, but I’ll go with THE WIND for it’s more auspicious cinematic style and its metaphorical underpinnings.
Hawthorne is my favorite American writer by the way, and his THE HOUSE OF THE SEVEN GABLES one of the novels I hold dearesr to my heart.