Director: Billy Wilder
Producer: Charles Brackett
Screenwriters: Billy Wilder, Charles Brackett, and D.M. Marshman Jr
Cinematographer: John F. Seitz
Music: Franz Waxman
Studio: Paramount Pictures 1950
Main Acting: William Holden and Gloria Swanson
How much more noir can you get than a dead guy narrating his own slow demise from beyond the grave? Face down in a swimming pool—that’s the first glimpse we catch of Joseph C. Gillis (William Holden). Quickly establishing the cynical dry wit Wilder specialized in, our expired chronicler guides us back in time to six months prior to fill us in on the details of how he finds himself floating lifeless in some luxurious looking estate’s recreational area. This haunting expose on the ills of Hollywood and how it discards talent at a rapidly callous rate dares us to understand what happens to some people who get what they wish for. Gillis plays a struggling screenwriter that through certain choices in his life scripts his own destruction.
Heartbreaking is the only way to describe seeing once-famous stars playing roles that must have hit way too close to home. Besides Swanson, watching two of the greatest silent directors Buster Keaton and Erich Von Stroheim representing symbols or stand-ins of the perilous nature of the movie business is powerful stuff. It really dawns on viewers about how fate and circumstance can deride one’s life beyond talent or accomplishments. No one can say that either of those two titans were incapable of succeeding in the industry once sound became a factor. Still, the underlying feeling is that they became disposable once Hollywood started to change its mode. A nostalgic look back at a forgotten cinema that was less than 25 years old and the participants who were cast aside. Great men reduced to mere afterthoughts tug at the heart and make us understand that anyone can become expendable in any facet of life.
Made in 1950, this is another example of how great that year was for classic film noir. Sunset Boulevard was no obscure picture made on some miniscule budget to grace the second half of a double bill. It was nominated for 11 Oscars including Best Picture and was a prestige flick if one ever existed. While it lost to All About Eve (one of the better Academy winners in history), it was a popular film that was astonishing for the way it criticized the very industry that created it.
A movie that every reader on this blog has probably seen does not merit much of a plot synopsis or retelling. However, some may not be aware of the many fascinating stories and backstage intrigue associated with the making of Sunset Boulevard. Montgomery Clift was signed to play the role that eventually went to Holden, but pulled out due to mysterious circumstances. Wilder was yelled at in public by Louis B. Mayer and was told that he was a disgrace. Many stars were offended by the no-holds-barred cynicism expressed. The film also explicitly name-drops all sorts of real celebrities and features throughout. It must’ve given the movie-going public an extra inside take on the gossip rags that probably already existed by then. Here was someone actually giving them some well informed dirt about Hollywood and it sure wasn’t pretty. Entertainment Weekly on the big screen tossing around all sorts of dirty laundry, but with an artist’s profound critical eye that makes the acidic ingredients go down smoothly. The satire to end all satire’s made more fascinating by it’s subject matter and who Wilder is lambasting.
Most Hollywood films are an illusion. The buying public gets sold a dream world rich with fantasies meant to indulge and arouse us. Expansive larger than life figures and locales, that like Martin Denny records of the 50′s, are mainly meant to transport us out of our ordinary boring lives. Sunset Boulevard though lifts the curtain on the wizard pulling the strings in the corner. It shows us that tinseltown is just like any other city or dead end place we all inhabit. Some of the people may be superficially glamourous and rich, but really they are not imbued with any special magic or star dust. They put their pants on one leg at a time and fight to survive their own particular rat race like any other working stiff in the US. You would think that after Billy Wilder dropped Sunset Boulevard on the collective human consciousness, that celebrity culture would die a slow death or at least become more trivial. Unfortunately this is not the case and new movie stars get reshuffled every couple of years, replacing those we have no more use for. By shining a light on the ugly face of superficiality and surface fame and/or infamy, Wilder creates a work of immense substance and power. The fact that his satirical warning on this diseased culture still reigns supreme even in this present day is surly not his loss but ours.








This was one of the films that I really thought had a shot at the No. 1 position.
A combination of Noir AND Horror, it’s got all the elements (as I understand) a great Noir film needs.
Along with THE APARTMENT, SUNSET is my favorite of all of Billy Wilders films and, like that Jack Lemmon/Shirley MacLaine vehicle, one of the most truthful and telling about the real cruelties of humanity (and a far cry from the over-rated/overblown and unfunny SOME LIKE IT HOT-this is jusy MY opinion guys!!!!). Watching Gloria Swanson come completely unwrapped is a real thing of performance beauty and I don’t think I have ever seen Holden better until he get to NETWORK in 1976.
Maurizio really threw me for a loop on this one.
What a crafty kid he is!!!!!!
Position #6 is rather high Dennis. Not trying to be crafty at all lol. I personally like Some Like It Hot more than The Apartment though the Wilder comedies always take a backseat to his more dramatic films (some which are black comedy anyway) for me.
Well, I never saw THE APARTMENT as a comedy. Yes, it has some comical moments threaded through the narrative and the moment Jack Lemmon strains spaeghetti with a tennis racquet is priceless, but the film is primarily a drama about the forgotten souls set awash in a careless bohemouth called NEW YORK CITY and how love fatefully, and sometimes, finds a way.
You’ll never convince me on SOME LIKE IT HOT. The length of the film is its biggest flaw. The film goes on forever with a premise that could have easily been popped off in an hour and 20 minutes. Plus, don’t bullshit me, there is no way that anyone could honesty mistake Jack lemmon and Tony Curtis for women even if the viewer were drunk, stoned and completely fucked up.
I know I may be in the minority on this film, it often gets cited as one of the greatest screen comedies of all time, but, frankly, i find the filom a tremendous bore and I don’t find the jokes funny at all. Wilder was best at drama laced with comedic overtones and NOIR…
Other than the big three Sam mentioned I also like Stalag 17 and Witness For The Prosecution. Some Like It Hot and The Apartment fall into that tier as well.
STALOG 17 has it’s moments, but its faded in opinion as a great film after years of debate when assessing Wilder. The three you love and THE APARTMENT are pretty much always called on when speaking of Wilders very best films. As cheesy as it has become I also have great admiration for THE LOST WEEKEND. Considering the year it was released I think Wilder had a lot of balls to give the public a film that was, for that time, so unflinching in its depiction of a subject as Alcoholism. For what it’s worth, most alcoholics were portrayed as lovable drunks or side characters up until that point in cinema. Wilder says no, it’s something that demands to be discussed, and rushes in and kicks the door open.
For me, its always been these four with Wilder:
1. SUNSET BLVD.
2. ACE IN THE HOLE
3. THE APARTMENT
4. DOUBLE INDEMNITY
I totally agree with Dennis, THE APARTMENT is a sad, serious film. As I said underneath it’s thread in the 50′s:
“Revisited this the other night… interesting to seek it out on the countdown (something I now plan on doing every time I watch an old movie that is in Allan’s countdown). Fun to read the old comments–one person even said one episode of ‘Mad Men’ is better! Ha! How daft!
I must say I think this is Wilder’s second best film (behind only ‘Ace in the Hole’) after these two it gets pretty neck and neck with all his classics (‘Sunset Boulevard’, ‘Double Indemnity’, ‘Lost in the Weekend’, and the very underrated ones: ‘Stalag 17′, ‘Witness for the Prosecution’, ‘The Fortune Cookie’, ‘One, Two, Three’, and ‘The Front Page’). This most recent viewing really made me think that this is the movie for celibates/asexuals. Perhaps this is me looking for something that is or isn’t there, but that’s what was most powerful to me this time. Think if Wilder could have used some Morrissey music on the soundtrack (‘I don’t mind if you forget me’ comes to mind)! Really a stone cold classic… after watching a Wilder I can’t get over how talented of a writer he was, it’s quite humbling.
Fun to read Vonnegut’s ‘DeadEye Dick’ with this one.”
I might need to revisit The Apartment again. It has been a while with that one as well (at least 7 years). Like with Dead Ringers, fresh eyes might see it differently. I always maintain that my opinion can change. No dice for The Lost Weekend though, which I just recently viewed again for the third time…. still a dated picture that does not move me.
JAMIE-THE APRTMENT was made in 1960.
all in all I have to agree with you though, his writing talent is something of legend and it’s truly amazing how well and easily he could pinball between comic moments and high sramatics, he has an ear for the cool and the charismatic speak that was trademark in films of the period.
I’d say, all in all he and Woody Allen are about neck and neck when it comes to writing skills and I’d go as far to say they were (and with Allen alive, is) two in the very highest tier of American screenwriters. The two of them write dialogue so fascinating and real that it baffles me that it all comes out of the single mind of one of these writers…
Oh right, the 60′s. And I even had to go and find in between LE SAMOURAI and VIRIDIANA. my apologies…
I’ll meet Maurizio half way and say I need to see LOST WEEKEND again.
Personally, I think ‘Some Like It Hot’ is the greatest farce on film. Once Curtis and Lemmon board that train and join the all-girl band the film takes off into the stratosphere, a world of its own that’s, well, surreal.
I never tire of it and see something new and hilarious every time I watch it – the way Curtis can’t figure out how to operate the motorboat, so he and Monroe ride backwards to the yacht. The cumulative effect of small comic bits like that make the film sublime.
And who else but Wilder could have made a farce that begins with the St. Valentine’s Day massacre?
Sugar: “I can stop drinking anytime I want to, only I don’t want to.” Heaven.
I’m with ya Mark, I think that last line in the film is one of the greatest ever, and also one of the most subversive. Late 50′s America, and a great accepting line that amounts to love between two men to end a film? Jesus.
There is so much I can say here but simply put SUNSET BOULEVARD is one of the greatest of all American films in any category, and for me Gloria Swanson’s performance is one of the greatest by a lead performer in movie history. Von Stroheim’s performance is unforgettable, the framing device a movie landmark, (yes the dead man narrating is indeed one of the most cynical approached to any film) and the corrosive underpinning and dialogue models of their kind. All that adds up to an easy Top 10 placement. There are three Wilder masterworks, (DOUBLE INDEMNITY and ACE IN THE HOLE are the other two of course) but I am always inclined to name this one my favorite, narrowly. I love the way you presented the film here, getting behind the scenes. It’s a film that doesn’t need plot summarizing, and one that rewards eternally on repeat viewings.
Well Sam we both completely agree on Wilder’s three best films. Before anyone thinks I only enjoy his noir work, I must confess to finding The Lost Weekend to be dated and not worth another viewing ever again. I would take Some Like It Hot over that film as well.
Yeah giving a plot summary for Sunset Boulevard is insulting the intelligence of the readers. I’m sure the whole of WITD has seen it.
I’d add THE APARTMENT to that group and make it an even 4 films…
God I didn’t know Clift was going to be in this… with what happened to him that would have been an even deeper subtext to all the silent era stars. Just a great film, nice work Maurizio.
That bottom screencap is one of my favorite film images.
Yeah the Clift subtext would of been interesting for sure. You couldn’t script something like that. The irony sure must of amused Wilder.
Frankly, I don’t think SUNSET BLVD. would be the classic it is today if Clift had been cast in the rolke Holden made famous. Clift was a great actor, no doubt about it, but he was swath in a self righteous seriousness he associated with being a superlative method thespian. Straight to the point, I don’t think he had the ability to reveal a dry wit of the kind of cynicism that was a trademark of Holden. With Swanson giving the film a tour-de-force dramatic turn, it’s really up to Holden to keep the film cynical and darkly humorous. In a nut-shell, Clift would have made the film even more brooding than it already was weighted SUNSET down so far it would have been long forgotten by now…
SUNSET is a classic because of it screenplay, it’s cinematography, it’s sharp wit and tight direction and its PERFECT cast…
Again, not just one of the greatest film noirs, but also one of the greatest movies ever made. Sunset Blvd & Asphalt Jungle were 2 movies that initiated me into the mesmerizing world of film noirs (I’d seen Maltese Falcon before that, but I’m not counting that cos I was then too young to appreciate good cinema), so evidently this film holds a special place in my heart.
Every aspect of the film was brilliant. What what added even greater dark irony to it was that, if I’m not wrong, Gloria Swanson featured as a leading lady in a number of silent films of Stroheim. So this fact made their characters in the film that much more biting and disturbing. Really, Wilder knew how to add insult to injury. Given that he was a filmmaker himself, I wonder what made him go for such a lashing, acerbic & nihilistic take on the movie industry.
Even Harold Robbin’s fascinating book on the movie industry, The Dream Merchants, was a devastating jab on the film industry in general, & Hollywood in particular… but Sunset Blvd.’s wasn’t just a hard jab, it was a full-bloodied kick on the nose.
Superb piece as always, Maurizio!!!
Well for me there are many noirs that transcend the genre and are simply great films. Sunset Boulevard sure is one of them. I think the fact that it criticizes the movie industry as opposed to the theater is why it lost to All About Eve at the Academy in 1950. Better to enjoy something that smacks someone else in the face than yourself. Boulevard is the better picture for me.
I totally agree with you logic on the Academy Awards for 1950. Now, this is not saying that ALL ABOUT EVE is a bad film at all. Matter of fact is that ALL ABOUT EVE is one of my favorite movies ever and it’s easy to see that it would have prevailed if SUNSET was not in the running at all. Now, while we cannot legimately conclude that SUNSET’s digs at the industry surely doomed the film in the eyes of the Academy, I’d say that it didn’t help its chances and the superlative notices for EVE just sealed SUNSET’s fate.
Frankly, I’d have given SUNSET the prize for PICTURE, DIRECTOR, SCREENPLAY, CINEMATOGRAPHY…
To keep EVE respectable I’d have tossed it ACTRESS for DAVIS and Supporting Actor for George Sanders…
Oh yeah Dennis I do think All About Eve was a fine film and a worthy Best Picture nominee. To be honest though it would just miss making my top five of that particular year.
It’s an apples and oranges debate, but I think it came down to two films in 1950 and because the Academy was pissed at the digs SUNSET made at the industry the second choice nabbed Oscar gold. Make no mistake, after SUNSET I’m sure EVE was right on its heels….
An American classic. nuff said
There are certain movies that while you’re watching, you’re thinking “there is nothing better than this.” This is in that category for me. It’s a must see for anyone who watches movies.
I agree Jon. I felt the same way about Sunset. Watching it you just know movies can’t get much better.
Hi! Maurizio…
I finally, caught-up to (Oops! I meant with…) your countdown…Now, to comment on Wilder’s “Sunset Blvd…” I have viewed this film on several occasions.
First Of all,
What another well-opinionated, thought-provoking, and well-written review Of Wilder’s 1950 film “Sunset Blvd.” [Thanks, for sharing all the behind the scenes facts, too...]
…and Secondly,
Here goes a couple Of quotes from Wilder’s Sunset Blvd… that are considered classics:
Joe Gillis: (William Holden)
You’re Norma Desmond. You used to be in silent pictures. You used to be big.
Norma Desmond: (Gloria Swanson)
I am big. It’s the pictures that got small.
Joe Gillis (William Holden)
I knew there was something wrong with them.
_____________________________________
Joe Gillis (William Holden)
Audiences don’t know somebody sits down and writes a picture. They think the actors make it up as they go along.
_____________________________________
Norma Desmond (Gloria Swanson)
We didn’t need dialogue. We had faces!
Norma Desmond (Gloria Swanson)
All right, Mr. DeMille, I’m ready for my close-up.
Thanks, for sharing!
DeeDee
Great stuff Dee Dee!!!!
Maurizio, thanks for your thought-provoking essay. First, regarding Montgomery Clift’s having turned down the role of Joe, what I’ve read is that Clift was reluctant to play such a character because he was uncomfortable over the parallels to his own life at the time. As I recall. he was having (or just had) some kind of relationship with (singer, I think) Libby Holman, who was quite a bit older than Clift. At any rate, Holden was a more successful casting choice.
As great as All About Eve is, I agree with those who consider this to be a superior classic. It was probably too dark to win the top Oscar.
I think it’s worth noting the context of the times in which Sunset Boulevard was made. Maurizio refers to the 25-year time difference from this film back to the height of the silents. Today that doesn’t seem like much as 1986 doesn’t seem ancient to me. The difference with Sunset is, of course, the transition from silent to sound films. Also included in that time period, however, are the Great Depression and World War II — both of them major extended events of the century. When one combines these with the postwar economic boom and concurrent, forward-moving thrust during the 1950s to modern technology and consumerism, the silent films indeed seemed a world that most wished to forget. (Another classic film made about this time, Singin’ in the Rain, I believe suffered in popularity to a significant degree because of the era it depicted.)
“[Sunset Boulevard] shows us that tinseltown is just like any other city or dead end place we all inhabit. Some of the people may be superficially glamourous and rich, but really they are not imbued with any special magic or star dust.”
This and other portions say it all — how could I add any more?
For sure, Swanson’s work here is immense. Regarding Wilder’s other films, this may be my favorite, but I’m also endeared to the classic Some Like It Hot, as well as Double Indemnity and The Fortune Cookie. Witness for the Prosecution is a stupendous confection.
Sunset Boulevard and Hitchcock’s Shadow of a Doubt are two films I’ll drop anything for to watch whenever they show up on TV.
Great comment DE PLUME!!! Don’t forget Ace In The Hole when you do a Wilder filmography roll call. I won’t accept dissenters when it comes to that one lol. Your mention of the 25 year difference from 86 to now as opposed to 1925-1950 seems very accurate and true. All About Eve is a classic film, but I got 4 or 5 I consider superior from that year. Yet it still remains probably one of the better Best Picture winners.
Maurizio, I’m guilty of never having seen Ace In the Hole all the way through. But now I see it should be on my list.
Many have suggested that All About Eve would’ve been better if Gary Merrill and Hugh Marlowe had been better actors. I’m not so sure of that assessment. I am anxious, however, to see the remainder of your list.
I finally caught Ace in the Hole on Turner Classic Movies. It’s much better than I’d thought from the few minutes I’d seen previously. Thanks for motivating me to see it!
Just rewatched Sunset Blvd. the other day! But it occurred to me that perhaps Joe is the villain and Norma is the hero of the piece?
I go into a lengthy explanation why here:
http://theoncominghope.blogspot.com/2011/09/on-shower-philosophy-and-sunset.html