by Allan Fish
continuing the top 25 series, no.23
(USA 1934 70m) DVD1/2
California, here we come
p William le Baron d Norman Z.McLeod w Jack Cunningham story W.C.Fields, J.P.McEvoy ph Henry Sharp art Hans Dreier, John B.Goodman
W.C.Fields (Harold Bissonette), Jean Rouverol (Mildred Bissonette), Julian Madison (John Durston), Kathleen Howard (Amelia Bissonette), Tommy Bupp (Norman Bissonette), Baby le Roy (Baby Ellwood Dunk), Charles Sellon (Mr Muckle), Tammany Young (Everett Hicks), Morgan Wallace (Jasper Fitchmueller), Josephine Whittell (Mrs Dunk), T.Roy Barnes (salesman), Spencer Charters (guard), Del Henderson (Abernathy),
Paging Carl LaFong! It’s a Gift is one of the undisputed masterpieces of American screen comedy and W.C.Fields’ greatest film. No other film has got close to its surreal humour, its irreverence and its lopsided view of family life as a purgatory to be endured. At one point Fields threatens to hit his small son, reasoning the act away with a “he’s not going to tell me I don’t love him.” He used the same line in The Bank Dick a few years later, so it was obviously a favourite, but never was it better used (or more appropriate as the brat really is an advert for infanticide).
Harold Bissonette (pronounced Bis-On-Ay, surely an influence on TV’s Hyacinth Bouquet) is a small town grocer with a hapless braindead assistant and a family from hell, lead by a wife who is surely an advert for euthanasia. He dreams of buying an orange grove when their sick relative dies and his wife won’t hear of such irresponsibility, but Harold sells up his store and buys a ranch anyway from his prospective son-in-law. Yet even when it turns out that the ranch is a dud and the company try and refund him he refuses, thinking them to just want it back because it’s actually worth something.
Fields is undoubtedly one of life’s unfortunates, but always seems to come out on top. He may endure hardship upon humiliation upon disgrace, but he bears it all with only the help of his trusty liquor flask. Never in all Fields’ films has he encountered such troubles. Firstly there’s the hilarious grocer’s routine with the poor customer who never gets his kumquats and that legendary weapon of mass destruction, the unaccompanied deaf and blind man, Mr Muckle, who reduces the entire shop to rubble. Oh, and the brat from hell who lets molasses drip onto the floor. Yet topping even this is the extended ten minute plus sequence of Fields trying to get to sleep. Nagged to death by a wife who hears only what she wants to hear, he goes outside to the veranda hanging bench to get some sleep. Through the efforts of a leaden-shoed neighbour arguing with her mother what to get and where to go (“I’d like to tell you both where to go” Fields murmurs), a salesman looking for the aforementioned Mr LaFong, the horrific toddler from the shop dropping grapes into his mouth from above prompting Fields’ all-time great line “shades of Bacchus!“, a coconut that seems to think itself a lemming and the bench itself, which crashes to the floor on more than one occasion. We’ve all been there, trying to sleep while little things exaggerate themselves in the mind to the point where your own breathing seems to disturb you, but here it is intensified and amplified to the Nth degree until our poor fellow has really had enough. However, in spite of the greatness of both these scenes, my favourite has to be the shaving scene where Fields is interrupted by his blissfully unaware daughter and prevented from shaving until he has to resort to drastic measures. Throw in scenes such as Fields opening canned tomatoes with an axe, burning the deckchair he couldn’t open and levering himself out of an ashcan with a spade and you have a laugh a minute comedy.
As always the supporting cast merely orbit around the great man but Howard is horrific as the wife from your worst nightmare, Young is typically dead as the assistant and Sellon is beyond immortal as Mr Muckle. And though the contribution of director Norman McLeod (also of the Marx Brothers’ Horse Feathers) cannot be underestimated (it’s certainly his best directed film), this is Fields’ show all the way. His wife may tell him to “wake up and go to sleep.” (go figure!), but you’ll never be in danger of nodding off.
A wonderful film, and a superb review, Allan. As you say, an undisputed comic masterpiece. As per usual, you have made me want to see the film in question yet again!
Well, I won’t complain at that. Thanks, Alexander.
Great stuff Allan. Also my favorite Fields picture. When I first saw on TV as kid, I couldn’t believe any one person could be so side-splittingly funny. Thanks gain for another savoured childhood memory!
This is my favorite Fields film as as both Alexander and Tony corroborate, a masterpiece of comedy and one that takes us back many years.
I love the “Carl Lefong” bit with the spelling out of the name, the “shades of Bacchus” bit, and the old man crossing the street, and everything going wrong in the sleeping episode. And the old man crossing the street to and from the store with traffic running frantically that somehow doesn’t hit him.
Exemplary piece.
Thanks, Tony, I never saw it as a child, but made up for it since.
One of the funniest classic movies, but I personally like “The Bank Dick” a little more.
It’s close, and I love You’re Telling Me and Never Give a Sucker…, too.
…..No Bill, I think this one is better than “The Bank Dick” but I also like “The Man on the Flying Trapeze.”…….
What I always found the funniest in Fields was the way his wife and children treated him. I remember in the other film he was named after a synonym for “drunk.” In fact, all the names for him in all his films are hysterical.
Terrific review for a terrific movie.
Thanks, Joe. My favourite Fields name was Larson E.Whipsnade.
Now here’s one that will cheer you when you are blue. I have a copy of this, and I have watched it countless times. Nobody can match him.
This was the first W.C. Fields movie I ever saw and I remember falling out of my chair from laughing. Of course I later bought it on video and then on DVD. Regretably both miss the scene in which Fields gets an order by phone for 1 asperine, to be delivered 75 miles further on. On which he says “I’ll send the truck on”.
This ewas running on a cable PBS station last night and I had to see if Allan had an opinion. This is ABSOLUTELY W.C. Fields BEST FILM. The utter insanity of this lush walking through the world, making mistakes and causing accidents right and left, all the while commenting on the stupidity of other around him is achingly funny. Allan mentions the moment where Fields, the expert know-it-all opens a can of stewed tomatoes with an ax. Its a small. Moment but illustrates the pure sclemiel in a guy whose logic is sound, but execution way off. I love YOURE TELLING ME? as well, but ITS A GIFT is pure comic perfection. Fields might be my favorite comic performer of the period because he’s real. Loved this essay!